Lech Lecha Sermon
Rabbi Miriam's sermon - delivered Shabbat morning on 24th October 2026.
The Story of Abraham by ALICIA OSTRIKER
I started by reading the banner headline
The way you read the big print at the eye doctor
It said I AM THE LORD GOD
ALMIGHTY AND I LOVE YOU
ESPECIALLY. No problem. Very good.
One line down it said PACK UP,
I’M SENDING YOU OVERSEAS. It said
YOU WILL HAVE AS MANY CHILDREN
AS THERE ARE SANDS IN THE SEA
AND STARS IN THE SKY.
THEY WILL POSSESS THE LAND AND
I AM PERSONALLY GOING TO BLESS THEM.
The smaller print said: I am going
To bless them as long as they obey me.
Otherwise there may be
Certain repercussions. The even smaller
Print explained how we needed
A memorable logo for our organization
And he had just the ticket, a mark of absolute
Distinction, it would only hurt for a minute.
The print kept getting smaller and blurrier,
The instructions more bizarre.
Hold on, I interrupted. I’d like to check
Some of this out with my wife.
NO WAY. THIS IS BETWEEN US MEN.
AND IF YOU HAPPEN TO BE THINKING
ABOUT LOOPHOLES
FORGET IT. It said they preferred
Not to use strongarm techniques. It said
BEAR IN MIND, FRIEND,
YOU’VE ALREADY SIGNED ON.
Lech Lecha, it seems to me, contains the seeds of all Judaism. Ostriker’s poem encapsulates so many. Our peoplehood, our relationship with God, the laws we’ve been given - including brit milah, the value we place on children, and perhaps, as in the poem, the patriarchy.
Today I’m going to focus on Eretz Yisrael, because I see planted throughout the sedra the seeds of everything we are experiencing today.
It starts of course with God’s epic call to Avram:
לֶךְ־לְךָ מֵאַרְצְךָ וּמִמּוֹלַדְתְּךָ וּמִבֵּית אָבִיךָ אֶל־הָאָרֶץ אֲשֶׁר אַרְאֶךָּ׃
“Go forth from your native land and from your father’s house to the land that I will show you.
The Torah’s entire narrative is of the convoluted journey to this land. I would go so far as to say that the Torah is a love story about Eretz Yisrael. This parasha is where it all begins. No fewer than 6 times in this parasha alone, God promises that Avram’s descendents will inherit the land. That they will be in slavery for four hundred years but will return to the land.
And there is such tender love in Avram’s relationship with the land. Twice he walks the length and breadth of the land - the first ever yam l’yam hike. This love of the very land has echoed throughout our generations.
I remember getting off the plane, aged 16 on Israel tour, and a member of the group took four steps, shouting “one, two, three, four, mitzvah!”
This was likely a re-read of Rabbi Yochanan in the Gemara in Ketubot:
“Anyone who walks four cubits in the Land of Israel is assured of a share in the World to Come.”
A page later, the Gemara says that
“that the greatest of the sages would kiss the ground at the border of the Land of Israel and kiss its rocks and roll in its dirt.”
For the Rambam, even one who just walks in the land but doesn’t live there, has merit. And we know from the Rambam’s own biography that at a very difficult time in history, the 12th century, he managed to live in the land for 5 months.
A deep love of the land. But also, from this very parasha, a relationship fraught with complication. When Avram arrives in the land, Canaanites and Peruzzites are there. Other peoples who will eventually be dispossessed. Some of whom attack the Israelites in the later books of the Torah as they journey through the land. This one line, וְהַכְּנַעֲנִי אָז בָּאָרֶץ exercises our commentators and scholars for biblical critical reasons, but for me it has other echoes. Then as today, there have always been other people in this beloved land.
Also in this parasha is the parting of ways between Lot of Avram - divisions within our own Jewish family. It’s worth noting that even where there are bitter differences, Avram still will go all the way to save Lot when he is captured. We are still family, no matter how far apart we are.
And then, crucially, in our parasha, there are the relationships between Sarai and Hagar, Yitzhak and Yishmael, also seeded in this week’s parasha. Let’s say they don’t get off to a good start. Here’s what happened. After decades of infertility, Sarai (and it’s all her idea) suggests a biblical form of surrogacy where her maid-servant would have a child with her husband. It’s unclear whether the child would then be adopted or whether it would somehow unlock fertility for Sarai. Regardless, when the maid-servant Hagar does get pregnant, it goes horribly wrong. Hagar acts superior. Sarai, in her bitterness, is abusive to her to the point that Hagar runs away. An angel of God reassures her and encourages her to return. Hagar names the place after her vision of God, Be’er l’hai roi - the Well of the Living God who Sees. Take note of that name because it’s going to be significant. The child, Yishmael is born and for a while it seems he will be Avraham’s only heir.
In next week’s parasha, thirteen years later, Sarah gives birth to Yitzhak, miraculously at the age of 90. Something unsavoury happens after Yitzhak’s weaning feast - Ishmael is metzahek - playing in a sinister way with the baby. Sarah, filled with the desire to protect her child’s position, insists that Avraham send Hagar and Ishmael away, which he does, the next morning, with just a skin of water to sustain them on their journey to who knows where.
Not a good start to the relationship between Jews - children of Sarah and Yitzhak, and Muslims - children of Hagar and Ishmael. And we could say that this parasha seeds an antagonistic relationship for ever more. But thankfully just as the parasha is seeded with so many challenges, it is seeded with the kernels of possible solutions.
Because, it seems there is a buried sub-plot about Isaac and Ishmael, which Rabbi Sacks z”l shared in his Covenant and Conversation. He describes clues planted throughout Bereishit through the place name B’er l’hai roi. The first occurrence is in our sedra. The place named by Hagar and deeply linked with her.
The next time we hear this place name is in Chayei Sara, after Sarah’s death, when Abraham's servant is returning with the woman, Rebekah, who is to become Isaac's wife. The Torah describes the scene when she first sees Isaac in the distance. He is coming, we are told, from "Be’er Lahai Roi" to meditate in the field. What is this place, and why was Isaac there?
Rashi tells us he went there to be reconciled with his stepbrother after his mother's death. But more than that. To invite Hagar to return to her place by his father Avraham’s side, this time as a full wife.
The Torah tells us Avraham does go on to marry again after the death of Sarah - a woman named Keturah with whom he has six children. The sages say: Keturah - she was Hagar (it is not unusual for people in the Torah to have more than one name). She was called Keturah, said the sages,
"because her acts gave forth fragrance like incense, ketoret."
The Rabbis have good reason for seeing an unrecorded reconciliation between the two sides of the family. Avraham was buried, we are told, by Isaac and Ishmael. If Ishmael was sent away into the desert when Isaac was young, with total isolation between the stepbrothers, how could this have come to be? Would there not have been immense tension between them? The Be’er l’hai roi theory answers this lacuna.
But there is one more amazing detail. Bereishit 25:
“After the death of Abraham, God blessed his son Isaac. And Isaac settled near… Be’er l’hai roi.”
So after Sarah’s death, Hagar came to live with Avraham, Yitzhak and Rivka. And after Avraham’s death, they all moved to live in Be’er l’hai roi, presumably with Yishmael and his family.
In Rabbi Sacks’ words,
“The story the Sages pieced together is enthralling. Not only did Avraham feel guilty about the banishment of Hagar and Ishmael. So did Yitzhak, according to this interpretation. We know that Avraham did not want to send Ishmael away. The text (Gen. 21: 11) is explicit on this point. But Sarah was insistent, and G-d told Avraham to listen to her. Throughout the lifetime of Sarah, reconciliation was impossible. After her lifetime, however… The divided family was reunited.
… There is a story here of immense consequence for our time. Yes, there was conflict and separation; but that was the beginning, not the end. Between Judaism and Islam there can be friendship and mutual respect.”
On Thursday night, I met with Brother Amir from the Borehamwood Mosque, along with Rabbi David-Yehuda at Hertsmere Progressive Synagogue. We had a very deep and beautiful conversation. We spoke about prayer and food and fasting and inter-generational conflicts. And yes, we even talked about Israel and Brother Amir shared ideas he had for a future of peace. We in Borehamwood cannot solve much in Israel, but we can certainly do our part here in Elstree and Borehamwood. In Brother Amir’s words,
“by coming together, listening to each other and having honest conversations, we can build stronger relationships between our communities, even when we may not agree on everything.”
We are starting a dialogue group, between local Jewish and Muslim communities, and if you would like to be part of a small pilot, please come to speak with me. Because good local relationships is one thing we can do, and because reconciliation is in the model of Yitzhak going to Hagar and moving to be close to Yishmael, despite the huge pain and breach of their pasts.
I don’t want talk of reconciliation to sound glib or easy. It’s a really difficult time. It has been a week of violence in the west bank, from Jews, and yesterday a shooting aimed at Jews with several injured, including critically. We’re in the middle of unresolved violence. But we must not make the mistake of thinking that every Muslim represents that or supports that. And we too, in our own small and local way, can start the work of building bridges.
Everything is here in Lech Lecha. Our people’s deep love of Eretz Yisrael. Avraham tenderly walking the length and breadth of the land. The Canaanim and Peruzim in the land. Brit bein habetarim with the promise of exile and return. Division within our own Jewish family. The awful start to Yitzhak's relationship with Yishmael. All of our love and difficulty, and also I believe all the seeds of healing, reconciliation and blessing.




Comments