Pause for Thought - Celebrity Traitors
This week, Rabbi Miriam Lorie joins BBC Radio 2’s Pause for Thought to reflect on Celebrity Traitors, the appeal of a good lie, and the everyday balancing act between honesty, kindness and keeping the peace. Click here to listen in full: https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/p0pjybsq Or read below:
So Celebrity Traitors! We’re in the final week of the game based on deception and lies. As well as loving all the intrigue, and Claudia Winkleman’s outfits, as a rabbi, I’m pretty intrigued by how millions of us enjoy watching other people lie. Particularly because lying is something that is usually frowned upon, and in some contexts, illegal.
Now my husband Harris, who is probably the most moral person I know, would say “it’s just a game, so there are different rules to real life”. And he does have a ruthless alter-ego when he plays board games. But take James Acaster, the most reluctant traitor of all time, who tries to avoid lying in the show. I think a lie might have been teased out of him once but you can tell he wants to be a good guy, even in this game.
Back in the real world, it turns out that most of us lie quite a lot, according to one study, an average of 1.75 times in a 10 minute conversation. It could be something small like saying you like someone’s clothes, or that you’d like to meet them for coffee when really you don’t.
The journalist Radikha Sanghani decided that all those people-pleasing small lies were hiding her true feelings and blocking people she loved from getting to know the real her, so one day decided she was never going to lie again. She would squirm with discomfort telling someone something they didn’t want to hear, but stuck with her policy.
My Jewish tradition insists on honesty and justice. One of the ten commandments is not bearing false witness. But lies might be allowed for the sake of peace, to avoid humiliating someone, or for safety.
I don’t think I’m the lying type, but it's quite the minefield balancing total honesty with protecting other people and myself in multiple interactions every day.
Maybe that’s why I like The Traitors: I get to enjoy the brazen lies without the moral calculus. And if James Acaster wins ...I'll be absolutely delighted, while wondering how on earth he got away with it.




Comments